Thursday, November 24, 2005

Tidbits - Academic (and Jewish) Stuff

  • Ronnie Ellenblum is known for his book on Frankish settlement in Israel during the Crusader period. In it, he questioned the perception of Crusaders as alien invaders who cowered in castles and cities for protection - he showed that there was quite a bit of settlement going on in some areas. Moreover, he demonstrated that many of the castles were built in relatively safe areas, and thus can not be explained as mere fortresses. He also attacked the notion that the local population (Eastern Christian and Muslim) was uniformly hostile to the Crusaders. Now, Ellenblum is coming out with a new book on Crusader Castles, also meant to undermine simplistic notions of 'Crusaders VS everyone else' in the Middle East. Let's hope Ellenblum's second work turns out to be as thought-provoking as the first.
  • The latest issue of Israel Affairs is a veritable jem, loaded with informative and interesting articles, from a discussion of 'escapist' parties in Israel (Green Leaf, anyone?) to a long critique of Israel's radical academics. Well worth a trip to the nearest university library.
  • Also worth a trip is an article in the latest issue of Middle East Journal. The article is a discussion of the Lydda/Ramle controversy by Alon Kadish and Avraham Sela, two professors who wrote a book on the subject (with Arnon Golan) which was published in Hebrew in 2001. The subject itself is too long for a blog post, but suffice it to say that Kadish and Sela dispute (convincingly, IMO), Benny Morris' claim of a massacre in one of the mosques during the 12th of July, and make a strong case against the idea that the expulsion of the inhabitants of Lydda and Ramle was premeditated. Well worth the read, whatever side you're on.
  • ...and finally for something Jewish, as promised. Dr. Gur Alroey, author of an excellent study of Jewish immigrants to Israel during the second aliya (all the immigrants, not just the pioneers), has recently set up a database of names of Jews who contacted various agencies in an attempt to emigrate from the 'Pale of Settlement'. In their own words:
    ...The MJMD records are base on the applications of Jewish emigrants who applied to the JCA & ITO's information bureaux which were scattered all over the Pale of Settlement in the Russian Empire in the early twentieth century...In particular, the MJMD aims to understand the causes, characteristics and patterns of the Jewish Migration in the early twentieth century. In addition, the MJMD enables, via search engine, to look for relatives who possibly migrated through the two information bureaux...The MJMD invites the public to visit us at this site.
    I highly recommend that you do so.

That's all for now, folks. AIWAC

No comments: